“ My husband and I came here on a Sunday evening around 7pm and was seated immediately. The place's ambiance was nice with a fair amount of lighting for me to peruse the menu. Coming in, I was hungry and we ordered an app and each of us got the burger. The cauliflower dish was good! It had a decent amount of veggies (haha maybe should've gotten more fiber in our diet but whatever haha) but the sauce it came with was delicious! However, the star was the burger. The burger was cooked perfectly and the bun wasn't soggy! I especially loved the bun it came with but I don't know if I would want to pay this amount on burgers and fries again. Overall, if you haven't had it, definitely try! You will not be disappointed. You'll leave full and happy (if you love carbs :p) ”

“ A really good burger if you like a saucy drippy messy burger. The fries dipped in the saucy drippy mess were excellent. Good service. The lights were dim in the restaurant tonight so we really didn't get the full orange glow of the sauce. (And as such no photo.) ”

“ Emily is hands down my favorite restaurant for pizza in Brooklyn. Of course, you can't leave out the scrumptious Emmy Burger! The staff is always friendly and the vibe is cozy. I've never been disappointed by anything I have ordered and indulged in while dining at Emily's. My favorite pizza is The Emily. It's a white pizza with mozzarella cheese, finally chopped pistachios, truffle sottocenere, and honey. You might think pistachios and honey don't belong on pizza. Try it, and I can't imagine not loving it. The crust is thin with a good crunch, overall it's absolutely sublime. It's always my go to pizza at Emily's although, each pizza I've tried has been really good. My two second favorite pizza's are the Famous Original Dan's - a pink pizza with, vodka sauce, oregano, and mozzarella cheese. It isn't overpowering, but so yummy. My favorite red pizza is, the Modern - double pecorino, onion, and Zoe Tong Chili Crisp. The Raw Broccoli Salad, is the salad I tend to order the most frequently. It has Asian pears, dried cherries, radish, peanut and a great miso dressing. The Emmy Birger absolutely lives up to its hype and all the excellent reviews. Served on a pretzel bun, which is delicious, the burgers are very large, but it's hard to leave it over because it's so good. The caramelized onions and house sauce works to make burger perfection. The fries or crispy and have excellent flavor.. It's a Brooklyn must, enjoy every bite! ”

“ Quality of ingredients and dishes was solid, hence the 4 stars. But overall the flavors were out of balance, very very heavy. The burger didn't have much to cut the heaviness (I'd expect more pickles or a sauce to balance out the thick patty). We tried the birria pizza which was yummy but I'd prefer it as a taco since the carb-y pizza crust wasn't necessarily adding anything besides more weight to the dish. ”

“ amazing burger quick service. the burst of flavors and juiciness experienced with this burger is unmatched. Easily on my top 3 burgers. must try. ”

“ I've been hearing such good things about this place so I finally decided to try it for takeout. I ordered through their website and it was ready for pick up earlier than estimated! Got the Quinn pizza (white pie) with added sausage and it was sooooo good. So good that my mom who I shared it with, called two people to brag about it. We aren't fans of red sauce so this was right up our alley. The cheese blend was perfect and buttery. The crust was thin and crispy just how we like it! ”

“ I've been to Emmy's several times and finally made it to Emily. I came primarily for the burger. I love the pretzel bun. This was a solid burger. The colony is one of my favorite slices at Emmy Squared and found out that it comes as a standard round pie at Emily. Loved it here even more! - you get more pepperonis ;) ”

“ I must preface: I am normally not a burger guy. I am learning to appreciate a good burger, but it is not oft my first choice. Nonetheless, on my last night in New York I was lost. I had no idea what I wanted for dinner. I failed to dial in my cravings. I resorted to Yelp and Beli for some proximity searches. And, as fate would have it, I stumbled upon Emily. Oh my, I hope my girlfriend does not get jealous because I definitely was feeling some type of way after this meal. With a brick oven churning out some epic looking pies (it is a pizza joint after all) I ordered some wings to procrastinate my fateful decision even more: burger or pizza. The wings offered the clarity I needed. The gochujang and tangy ranch sent me into a trance. Crispy skin and just a bit of sweetness cleared the fog in my mind. The spice spoke to me. It told me to get the emmy burger. Oh, what a decision it was. It comes on an aluminum tray lined with parchment paper, crispy, thin fries in their own individual boat, a knife, and the star: a beautiful, brown pretzel bun caressing a perfectly medium rare burger that is dripping melted cheese, caramelized onions, and Emmy Sauce. It comes with a knife. Ignore it, take this meaty masterpiece with both fists and take one huge bite. Do not clean up. Let the juicy burger and emmy sauce drip down your face, onto your pants. This, after all, is a life altering burger. The pretzel bun is chewy, the caramelized onions and emmy sauce bring just enough sweetness, and that burger is jam packed with umami flavor. New York provided me with some great eats. And, it feels almost criminal to say a burger and fries were the best meal I had. But, dare I say, a burger and fries were the best meal I had. Emily, if my heart did not already belong to another woman it would be all yours. That burger shook me to my core. And, I will not recover until I come back and get another. ”

“ I've been here twice now since my friend put me on. Let me start off by saying that i'm not a big pizza girlie and it's only ever so often that I'll crave a slice or two. However this place? Stamping it as my official go-to place whenever I want my pizza fix. The inside is fairly small so expect to be close to the table next to you. Im talking the kind of close where you'll have to shift your table to get in and out. Service is relatively fast and all of the waitstaff are pretty friendly. We started with the calamari bc whenever there's calamari on the menu, i'm ordering it! The breading was perfect and the calamari was flavorful and crispy. I enjoyed the duo a special mayo and some marinara. (How all fried calamari should be served, in my opinion). For our entree we decided to split the colony pie. It's a red pizza with cheese, pepperoni, pickled jalapeños and topped with some hot honey. Whoever invented honey on pizza is genius because it's the perfect combo of salty and sweet. The pizza toppings to cheese to sauce ratio was perfect. Personally I think one is good to share between two people but if you're a group -- def opt to get more! Although we were feeling stuffed, the table next to us convinced us to get the banana pudding for dessert. It DID NOT DISAPPOINT. It's the type of banana pudding that would give Magnolias a run for their money. (Sorry not sorry) ”